Error and the growth of experimental knowledge
Mayo, 1996. §1.2, §1.3, §6.2.
- Publisher
- University of Chicago Press
- ISBN
- 9780226511979
- Shelf
- Severity and error
- Concepts
- Severity, Falsification
Why it is hereThe severity requirement the programme rests on starts in this book: a test counts only if it would very probably have found the error, had the error been there.
The underlinings across the pages
pp. 3–12 · 18 marks
pp. 177–183 · 14 marks
structure (red in Zotero) definition (green) key passage (yellow) book pages · pages not read are folded
1.2 Day-to-day learning from mistakes
pp. 4–7
Unless one asks for certainty, there is no reason to think errors go unnoticed and block inquiry. Ask how we actually catch our mistakes and you are already past Popper and Lakatos.
- After-trial checking Once the data are in, check the tentative conclusion with techniques learnt from past mistakes, such as looking at what happens without the suspected factor; and correct, by averaging repeated measurements.
- Before-trial planning Avoid known errors before collecting data: the teacher who grades blind is an informal version of control groups, double blinding and large samples.
- An error repertoire A field’s history of mistakes becomes a checklist: is the correlation spurious, is there an extraneous factor, are cause and effect inverted?
- The effects of mistakes Knowing what an error does, and how much, lets you rule it out as the cause or subtract it afterwards.
- Simulating errors Show, with real or artificial means, what the result would look like if the error were there.
- Amplifying error patterns Magnify a small error until it shows, or study deviations from a known standard.
- Robustness Know when breaking an assumption does no harm, and vary the assumptions to see whether the result holds.
- Severely probing error Steps 1–7 are the basis of arguing from error: a procedure that would very probably reveal a specific error if present, and not otherwise. If it finds nothing, the error can be inferred absent.
p. 7“an overwhelmingly good chance of revealing the presence of a specific error”
C033 →Working method
1.3 Accentuate the positive, eliminate the negative
pp. 8–11
Popper cannot say why passing a severe test counts in a hypothesis’s favour; for Mayo a test is severe only if it could have caught the ways the hypothesis can be wrong.
6.2 The (error-)severity requirement
pp. 178–183 · an extract with a card of its own
Evidence counts for a hypothesis only if it fits the hypothesis and the test that produced it would very probably have gone the other way, had the hypothesis been false.
The extract: The severity requirement →Claims drawn from this card
Each claimA sentence from a source, kept verbatim, that the programme stands on, uses or has to answer to. shows its ENTIAThe notation this site uses on itself: what each piece is for, read through five layers. functionWhat a claim does for the programme: a conceptual tool, a working method, corrective evidence, a technical reference.; open + for its stanceHow the programme holds the claim: assumed, used, or contested., claim typeWhat kind of statement it is, so that the right test can be applied. Proposed until checked by hand. and relationsHow one claim bears on another, in the CiTO vocabulary: refines, extends, presupposes, confirms, contests..
Paraphrase CC BY-NC 4.0, Claudio Cammarano. Quoted passages belong to their author and are kept short; the text itself is not distributed. Notes from the Zotero library, updated weekly.