C013
In their own words · Mayo 2018 · p. 14, Excursion 1, Tour I, §1.2 · assumed
…I also advocate the positive counterpart: Severity (strong):
“We have evidence for a claim C just to the extent it survives a stringent scrutiny. If C passes a test that was highly capable of finding flaws or discrepancies from C, and yet none or few are found, then the passing result, x, is evidence for C.”
One way this can be achieved is by an argument from coincidence.…
The positive counterpart of the weak requirement: evidence is graded by how capable the test was of finding flaws. It matters because it turns severity from a veto into a measure, which is what a validation protocol needs to rank results rather than just reject them.
The five layers, for this claim
1 Free tag Mayo a name finds, it does not vouch
2 Topic Severity closed list
3 Theme How a verdict is made derived from the topic
4 Concept Severity a note and links
5 Geometry 1 1 peer-reviewed
The same core in the infographic, with the claims it touches.
Relations
- extends → C012 Agreement between data and a claim is not evidence when the method could not have found the claim false. Moves from a negative veto (no test, no evidence) to a positive, graded criterion.
- ← refines C015 Absence of a detected error counts only if the procedure would have signalled that error had it been there. Specifies severity as a property of the error-detecting procedure, conditional on the error being present.
- ← presupposes C017 Severity is applied one level up, to methods rather than to claims: a method is judged by its capacity to catch erroneous interpretations. Applying severity to methods presupposes the graded criterion it applies to claims.
- ← confirms C040 A test does not collect agreement; it looks for consequences that would be surprising if the hypothesis were false. The same demand, a test highly capable of finding the claim false, stated before severity had a name.
Notation
- Claim typeWhat kind of statement it is, so that the right test can be applied. Proposed until checked by hand.
- D1.8 · ethical-normative
- FunctionWhat a claim does for the programme: a conceptual tool, a working method, corrective evidence, a technical reference.
- conceptual tool
- StanceHow the programme holds the claim: assumed, used, or contested.
- assumed
- Cite this
- claudiocammarano.com/en/claims/c013/