Claims › Concept · What a machine cannot be said to do

Claim type

Does the kind of a claim decide how it can be checked?

What kind of claim something is decides how it can be checked at all: the ontology comes before the epistemology.

Where it sits

1 Free tag Cammarano a name finds, it does not vouch
2 Topic Claim types closed list, one per claim
3 Theme What a machine cannot be said to do derived from the topics
4 Concept Claim type · 6 claims a note and links, or no build
5 Geometry 1 1 0.75 0.75 0.5 0.5 source, use, dissent

How its claims lean on each other

1 · Free tag2 · Topic3 · Theme4 · Concept5 · Geometryweight, 0.5 → 2The claimsCammaranoCammaranoCammaranoCammaranoClaim typesClaim typesWhat a machine cannot be said to doWhat a machine cannot be said to doClaim typeClaim typeAlso: Measurement artefactC001C001 · Before asking whether a statement is true, you have to settle what kind of statement it is: the test that fits a measurement does not fit a value judgement.C046C046 · Conceptual frameworks are made, not given, and can be rebuilt critically.C002C002 · Two claims of different kinds share no standard of truth, so a procedure that works on one returns a meaningless verdict on the other.C003C003 · One dimension of the taxonomy decides what a claim is; the other six describe how it behaves once that is settled.C004C004 · A measurement, an experiment and an argument are accountable to different things, so they cannot be asked to share one document and one standard of proof.C005C005 · Two independent findings pointing the same way is not evidence that they are connected.C001 refines C002C003 extends C001C004 extends C001

The claims

  1. C001

    “You cannot determine whether a claim is true without first establishing what type of claim you are dealing with.”

    Before asking whether a statement is true, you have to settle what kind of statement it is: the test that fits a measurement does not fit a value judgement. The whole framework rests on taking that step first, and in the open.

    Building the Taxonomy ¶4 · ¶4 · assumed · weight 1 · refines C002 · open C001

  2. C046

    “The idea that we live and die in the prison of our 'conceptual framework' was developed primarily by Kant: pessimistic Kantians thought that the real world is for ever unknowable because of this prison, while optimistic Kantians thought that God created our conceptual framework to fit the world. But revolutionary activists believe that conceptual frameworks can be developed and also replaced by new, better ones; it is we who create our 'prisons' and we can also, critically, demolish them.”

    Conceptual frameworks are made, not given, and can be rebuilt critically. The programme’s taxonomy is such a framework: a prison it built and has to be ready to demolish.

    Lakatos 1978 · p. 20, ch. 1 · assumed · weight 1 · open C046

  3. C002

    “A statistical claim and a normative claim share nothing in their truth conditions — treating them as interchangeable is the error the framework is designed to prevent.”

    Two claims of different kinds share no standard of truth, so a procedure that works on one returns a meaningless verdict on the other. The failure is not getting the answer wrong; it is applying the wrong test and not noticing.

    Building the Taxonomy ¶4 · ¶4 · assumed · weight 0.75 · open C002

  4. C003

    “The remaining dimensions […] operate as modifiers that describe how a given claim type behaves epistemically.”

    One dimension of the taxonomy decides what a claim is; the other six describe how it behaves once that is settled. Keeping a single axis load-bearing is what stops the scheme from flattening into a list of labels.

    Building the Taxonomy ¶3 · ¶3 · assumed · weight 0.75 · extends C001 · open C003

  5. C004

    “Measurements and experiments are answerable to data and to a coding protocol. Arguments are answerable to other arguments.”

    A measurement, an experiment and an argument are accountable to different things, so they cannot be asked to share one document and one standard of proof. This is the taxonomy’s own principle turned on the programme’s publication plan, and it is what split the working paper in two.

    What Counts as One Paper ¶10 · ¶10 · used · weight 0.5 · extends C001 · open C004

  6. C005

    “A convergence between two lines of evidence is not the same as a link between them, and writing it up as though it were would be the category collapse this project exists to catch.”

    Two independent findings pointing the same way is not evidence that they are connected. The rule is applied here against the programme’s own interest, on a convergence it would have been convenient to claim.

    What Counts as Introspection ¶11 · ¶11 · used · weight 0.5 · refines C020 · open C005

Reading cards on this concept

All 15 concepts →All the claims, one by one →